Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss Trial of Ex-Officer in Fatal Shooting

UPDATE: A judge has just denied a motion to dismiss the trial against former San Leandro police officer Jason Fletcher, who is accused of fatally shooting Steven Taylor in 2020. This critical ruling was made on July 14, 2023, and marks a significant moment for Taylor’s family, who have fought tirelessly for justice.

Outside the Alameda County Superior Courthouse, emotions ran high as family members expressed their relief. Addie Kitchen, Taylor’s grandmother, stated, “Five years and 7 months, we have been fighting just to get to this point.” Her voice reflected the pain and perseverance of a family seeking accountability in the wake of tragedy.

The case revolves around the events at a Walmart in San Leandro, where Taylor was shot under controversial circumstances. He was accused of shoplifting and allegedly wielded a baseball bat when Officer Fletcher confronted him. Despite attempts to de-escalate the situation, including the use of a Taser, Fletcher ultimately shot Taylor, leading to charges of voluntary manslaughter due to the use of unreasonable deadly force.

Kitchen had previously urged the judge in a letter to honor the family’s rights, highlighting delays that have plagued the case. “I’m glad that the judge felt the need to present the case to a jury. Let the jury make a decision,” she said, emphasizing the importance of public scrutiny in such matters.

Critics, including Cat Brooks, Executive Director of the Anti-Police Terror Project, have accused the district attorney of failing to adequately represent the community. Brooks stated, “Your job is to represent the people, and we are the people. Nancy O’Malley, the district attorney who charged this cop, had never charged a cop in her entire tenure.” The frustration is palpable as the community rallies for justice, demanding accountability for law enforcement actions.

The impact of this case reaches far beyond the courtroom. Taylor’s family insists he struggled with mental health issues and was known to the San Leandro Police Department prior to the incident. His mother, Sharon Taylor, expressed gratitude that the charges were not dismissed, stating, “I’m grateful that this wasn’t dismissed. Pushed under the rug.”

With the trial now set to proceed, the family and supporters are hopeful for a fair jury decision. The next steps will be closely watched as the trial unfolds, with implications that could resonate throughout California and beyond.

This case underscores the ongoing national conversation surrounding police accountability and the treatment of individuals with mental health challenges. As the trial approaches, the community remains vigilant, demanding justice for Steven Taylor and advocating for systemic change.

Stay tuned for ongoing updates on this developing story, as the trial is poised to shine a light on critical issues of law enforcement practices and community relations.