Pete Alonso Hits Free Agency: Mets, Red Sox, and More Eye Star

UPDATE: Pete Alonso is officially back on the free agent market, and the clock is ticking for teams to make their move. Just moments after the Mets’ crushing loss to the Miami Marlins on October 1, 2025, Alonso announced his intention to opt out of his $54 million contract, setting the stage for a potentially explosive offseason.

This is a pivotal moment for Alonso, who is coming off a resurgent season where he posted a remarkable .272 batting average with 38 home runs and 126 RBIs. His performance has significantly boosted his market value, making him one of the most sought-after free agents in Major League Baseball.

Alonso’s durability is also noteworthy; he has played in all 162 games for two consecutive seasons and has been a consistent presence for the Mets since his debut in 2019. With a franchise record of 264 career home runs, he has solidified his status as a fan favorite.

As we look at the landscape, several teams are already emerging as potential suitors for the five-time All-Star. Here’s a breakdown of where he could land:

New York Mets: Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns expressed a desire to bring Alonso back, citing his “really good offensive” capabilities. However, with the team’s focus on improving their pitching staff, Alonso’s return is uncertain. Internal options like Mark Vientos and Juan Soto could fill the first base and designated hitter roles, complicating Alonso’s future in New York.

Boston Red Sox: After a lackluster season with a .244 average at first base and only 16 home runs, the Red Sox are in desperate need of a power bat. With Craig Breslow, the new president of baseball operations, keen on making bold moves, Alonso could split time at first base and DH if signed. The Red Sox have cleared significant payroll by trading Rafael Devers, leaving them with room to invest.

Cincinnati Reds: Although not an obvious fit, the Reds are looking to bolster their offense. Alonso’s presence would add significant power, but it would require a record-setting contract for the franchise. The Reds are projected to have a $120 million competitive balance tax payroll next season, so they might be cautious about making such a splash.

Philadelphia Phillies: With Bryce Harper currently at first base, Alonso’s fit depends on whether the Phillies re-sign Kyle Schwarber. If Schwarber departs, Alonso could seamlessly fill the offensive gap. The Phillies have shown a willingness to spend, making them a contender for Alonso’s services.

Pittsburgh Pirates and Baltimore Orioles: Both teams are looking to improve their lineups and have expressed interest in acquiring a powerful bat. The Pirates want to complement their strong pitching rotation, while the Orioles are seeking to add more slug to their offense.

As the clock ticks down on free agency, the urgency is palpable. Teams are scrambling to finalize their rosters, and Alonso’s decision could reshape the future of multiple franchises.

Stay tuned for further updates as this story develops. The next few weeks will be crucial for Alonso and the teams vying for his talents.