Discovering the Legacy of Seymour Hersh in Netflix’s ‘Cover-Up’

The new documentary, Cover-Up, now available on Netflix, delves into the life and work of acclaimed investigative journalist Seymour Hersh. Co-directed by Laura Poitras, who won an Academy Award for Citizenfour, and Mark Obenhaus, the film reflects on Hersh’s decades-long career, particularly his groundbreaking reports on U.S. military actions during the Vietnam and Iraq wars. The documentary, which has already been shortlisted for the 2026 Oscars, showcases Hersh’s determination to uncover the truth, despite his reluctance to reveal sources or discuss his personal experiences.

Hersh, now 88 years old, embodies the archetype of a journalist, often depicted with an askew tie, a disheveled appearance, and surrounded by stacks of papers. His career began in an era that demanded tenacity and a commitment to uncovering uncomfortable truths. As he recounts his early experiences, Hersh reflects on the influence of his father, who owned a laundromat, fostering his love for engaging with people—a skill that would later prove invaluable in his journalistic pursuits.

In Cover-Up, Hersh discusses the pivotal moments of his career, including his reporting on the My Lai massacre in 1969. This tragic event, where U.S. troops killed hundreds of Vietnamese civilians, marked a turning point in his career, establishing him as a leading voice in investigative journalism. His fearless reporting has led to significant revelations, including the torture of prisoners at Abu Ghraib and the implications of the Watergate scandal.

Hersh’s candidness about the emotional toll of his work adds depth to the documentary. He openly shares how the atrocities he reported on affected him personally, revealing moments of vulnerability. “You’re getting me to think about things I don’t want to think about,” he tells Poitras during an interview. This honesty lends a human touch to the film, illustrating the complex relationship between a journalist and the often harrowing realities they uncover.

The documentary does not shy away from controversy. Hersh’s confrontational style is evident as he engages with Poitras, demonstrating his unwillingness to compromise on his principles. He acknowledges that his reporting has made him a target, stating, “Nobody likes the messenger,” a sentiment that encapsulates the challenges faced by investigative journalists.

While the film reflects on Hersh’s remarkable contributions to journalism, it also serves as a critique of the current state of the profession. It raises questions about the prevalence of access journalism and the pressures that inhibit reporters from pursuing the truth. By highlighting Hersh’s commitment to accountability, the documentary implicitly critiques a media landscape where many fear challenging powerful interests.

Despite the challenges of modern journalism, Hersh remains an indomitable figure. He continues to write independently on platforms like Substack, showcasing his resilience and adaptability in an evolving media environment. His willingness to acknowledge past mistakes, including an incident where he was misled by fraudulent documents, demonstrates a commitment to integrity that is often lacking in contemporary journalism.

In summary, Cover-Up is more than just a retrospective on Hersh’s life; it is a poignant examination of the role of journalism in society. The documentary captures the essence of a man who has dedicated his life to exposing the truth, regardless of the personal cost. Through its engaging storytelling and thoughtful reflections, the film invites viewers to consider the importance of accountability in journalism and the enduring spirit of those who dare to challenge the status quo.

For those interested in a compelling exploration of investigative journalism and its impact, Cover-Up is a must-watch.